modeling the effects of land use on water quality parameters using ols and gwr multivariate regression methods in fars province watersheds

نویسندگان

مریم حسین خواه

دانشکده منابع طبیعی دانشگاه ارومیه گروه آموزشی مرتع و آبخیزداری مهدی عرفانیان

عضو هیات علمی رسمی دانشکده منابع طبیعی دانشگاه ارومیه گروه آموزشی مرتع و آبخیزداری احمد علیجانپور

دانشکده منابع طبیعی دانشگاه ارومیه گروه آموزشی جنگلداری

چکیده

extended abstractintroductionin recent years, several studies around the world have shown that land use has a strong impact on water quality, and significant correlations exist between water quality parameters and land use types. generally land use types have adverse impacts on water quality, so positive relationships exist between percentages of these land use types and concentrations of water pollutants. in other words, negative relationships are usually found between percentages of un-developed lands (e.g. forest and rangelands) and concentrations of water pollutants (good water quality). in contrast, higher percentages of these developed land use types are related to higher concentrations of water pollutants (worse water quality). the relationships between different land use types and different water quality parameters vary greatly, and a land use type might be positively associated with one water pollutant but negatively related to another. the relationships between water quality and land use are usually analyzed by conventional statistical methods such as ordinary least squares regression (ols). in recent years, a simple but powerful statistical method named geographically weighted regression (gwr) has been developed to explore the continuously varying relationships over space. similar to ols, gwr builds a model to analyze how one dependent variable changes in response to the change in one or more independent variables, and it can calculate a set of local regression results including local parameter estimates. this study applied the gwr technique to explore the spatially varying relationships between land use and water quality in 42 watersheds located in fars province, iran. the main objective of this study is to explore how the relationships between land use and water quality indicators change over space over selected watersheds. materials and methodsthe present study was carried out in fars province, iran, and water quality data from 1971 to 2011 were obtained from the water company authority in fars. the water quality parameters consist of ca, cl, ec, co3, hco3, k, mg, na, ph, th, sar, so4 and tds. seven land use types, including bare soils, rangelands, fallow, agricultural, orchards, residential and forest lands, were selected in this study in this study. the land use map was created and validated by utilizing the landsat tm images (12 frames in july 2010) based on the widely-used remote sensing technique known as the maximum likelihood method. the spatially varying relationships between land use and water quality indicators were analyzed using gwr. water quality indicators were used as dependent variables, while land use indicators were independent variables. because high correlations exist among the land use indicators, each gwr model used only one land use indicator to analyze its association with one water quality indicator. there were seven land use indicators and thirteen water quality indicators. therefore, the relationships for 91 (13 times 7) pairs of water quality and land use indicators were analyzed by building 91 gwr models. gwr analyses were conducted using gwr4 software package. afterwards, the local parameter estimates, the values of t-test on the local parameter estimates, and the local r2 values produced by the gwr models were mapped to give a clear visualization of the spatial variations in the relationships between land use and water quality, and the abilities of the land use indicators to explain water quality. all mappings and gis analyses were performed using the arcgis 9.3. the ols models are like the following: (1)y represents the dependent variable, is the intercept, and is the coefficient and the independent variable, represents the error term, and p is the number of independent variables. the gwr model differs in that it incorporates the coordinates of each location “i” with a metric coordinates “u” and it is defined as: (2) the model gwr is calibrated using an exponential distance decay function: (3)the weight of site “j” as it effects site “i”, w is calculated using the distance (d) between sites “i” and “j” with selecting “b” as the bandwidth. the weight decreases rapidly when the kernel is smaller than the distance. for this study, an adaptive band was used because the density of sample sites varied across the study area. we used the global moran’s i statistics for the residuals of both ols and gwr models to test spatial dependence (autocorrelation). global models assume that relationships between water quality and explanatory variables are the same across space. this is particularly problematic given the variation in land cover and multiple sources of pollutants. to evaluate two model performances, we utilized the coefficient of determination (r2) and the corrected akaike’s information criterion (aicc). the purpose of comparing gwr with ols models was to identify whether gwr models have better model performance than the corresponding ols models. the comparison was performed by comparing the model r2 and the aicc values from both gwr and ols models. a lower aicc indicates a closer approximation of the model to reality, lower aicc means better model performance. results and discussionthe global r2 of gwr with comparison of r2 of ols for each pair of dependent variable (water quality indicator) and independent variable (land use indicator) indicate that a dramatic improvement in r2 of gwr over ols is observed for every pair of water quality and land use indicators. the r2 values in gwr in all watersheds were larger than 0.83 and the aicc for all water quality parameters were much smaller than the ols models. the higher values of the global r2 from gwr than the r2 from ols indicate the improvement in model performance of gwr over ols. however, the statistical significances of the improvements need to be verified with aicc values. the statistical test results for improvement in model comparisons of the aicc value indicates a closer approximation of the model to reality. thus, in this study, a gwr model is considered to be significantly improved from its corresponding ols model if the aicc value of the gwr is at least three lower than that of the ols and the f-test is significant at p-value < 0.05 level. the spatial maps of the gwr model parameters, reproduced for the study area in the arcgis 9.3 for ec and cl showed that rangeland, fallow lands, orchards and residential in the southeast, bare soil and agricultural lands in the north, and forest lands in the southwest of fars province, have the significant increasing impact on ec indicator values. furthermore, bare soils, rangelands, fallow and forest regions in the west, agricultural areas in the southwest, orchards and residential areas in the south of this province have decreasing impact on ec values. for the case of chloride (cl), bare soils, rangelands, agricultural areas and forest in the north, orchards and fallow lands, in the southeast and residential zones in the east show a significant increase impact on this indicator. in addition, bare soils in the northwest, rangelands, fallow lands and forest in central zones, orchards and residential in the south, agricultural lands in the southwest of this province, have not significant increase on the chloride.conclusionthis study examined the relationships between seven land use types (%) and thirteen water quality indicators using both ols and gwr models in 42 watersheds of fars province, iran. most gwr models show great improvements of model performance over their corresponding ols models, which is proved by f-test and the comparisons of model r2 and aicc from both gwr and ols. many gwr models also successfully reduce spatial autocorrelations examined by moran&apos;s i statistics. the gwr models improved the reliabilities of the relationships between variables by reducing the spatial autocorrelations in residuals. the visualization of the gwr model local parameter estimates (beta maps), and local r2 maps in arcgis, highlight the great spatial variations in the impacts of different land use types on different water quality indicators and help identify their spatial patterns.

برای دانلود باید عضویت طلایی داشته باشید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

on the relationship between using discourse markers and the quality of expository and argumentative academic writing of iranian english majors

the aim of the present study was to investigate the frequency and the type of discourse markers used in the argumentative and expository writings of iranian efl learners and the differences between these text features in the two essay genres. the study also aimed at examining the influence of the use of discourse markers on the participants’ writing quality. to this end the discourse markers us...

15 صفحه اول

the effects of error correction methods on pronunciation accuracy

هدف از انجام این تحقیق مشخص کردن موثرترین متد اصلاح خطا بر روی دقت آهنگ و تاکید تلفظ کلمه در زبان انگلیسی بود. این تحقیق با پیاده کردن چهار متد ارائه اصلاح خطا در چهار گروه، سه گروه آزمایشی و یک گروه تحت کنترل، انجام شد که گروه های فوق الذکر شامل دانشجویان سطح بالای متوسط کتاب اول passages بودند. گروه اول شامل 15، دوم 14، سوم 15 و آخرین 16 دانشجو بودند. دوره مربوطه به مدت 10 هفته ادامه یافت و د...

15 صفحه اول

the effects of keyword and context methods on pronunciation and receptive/ productive vocabulary of low-intermediate iranian efl learners: short-term and long-term memory in focus

از گذشته تا کنون، تحقیقات بسیاری صورت گرفته است که همگی به گونه ای بر مثمر ثمر بودن استفاده از استراتژی های یادگیری لغت در یک زبان بیگانه اذعان داشته اند. این تحقیق به بررسی تاثیر دو روش مختلف آموزش واژگان انگلیسی (کلیدی و بافتی) بر تلفظ و دانش لغوی فراگیران ایرانی زیر متوسط زبان انگلیسی و بر ماندگاری آن در حافظه می پردازد. به این منظور، تعداد شصت نفر از زبان آموزان ایرانی هشت تا چهارده ساله با...

15 صفحه اول

Exploring the relationship between land use and surface water quality using multivariate statistics in arid and semi-arid regions

The relative impacts of different types of land use on the surface water quality are yet to be ascertained and quantified. In this paper, the influence of different types of land use on surface water quality is investigated. Rain events samples from different land use in the central plateau, Iran, were analyzed for major ions. Statistical analyses were employed to examine the statistical relati...

متن کامل

Determining Effective Factors on Gullies Development in Mazayjan Watershed, Fars Province, Using Multivariate Statistical Methods

Gully erosion is one of the causes of land degradation, which causes a lot of damage with the loss of fertile soil. For this purpose, in the present study, using the Cochran relation, 40 gullies were selected for measurement in the Mazayjan watershed located in the southeast of Fars province. Factor analysis method was used to determine the factors affecting the classification of samples. Backw...

متن کامل

منابع من

با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید


عنوان ژورنال:
محیط شناسی

جلد ۴۲، شماره ۲، صفحات ۳۵۳-۳۷۳

کلمات کلیدی
extended abstractintroductionin recent years several studies around the world have shown that land use has a strong impact on water quality and significant correlations exist between water quality parameters and land use types. generally land use types have adverse impacts on water quality so positive relationships exist between percentages of these land use types and concentrations of water pollutants. in other words negative relationships are usually found between percentages of un developed lands (e.g. forest and rangelands) and concentrations of water pollutants (good water quality). in contrast higher percentages of these developed land use types are related to higher concentrations of water pollutants (worse water quality). the relationships between different land use types and different water quality parameters vary greatly and a land use type might be positively associated with one water pollutant but negatively related to another. the relationships between water quality and land use are usually analyzed by conventional statistical methods such as ordinary least squares regression (ols). in recent years a simple but powerful statistical method named geographically weighted regression (gwr) has been developed to explore the continuously varying relationships over space. similar to ols gwr builds a model to analyze how one dependent variable changes in response to the change in one or more independent variables and it can calculate a set of local regression results including local parameter estimates. this study applied the gwr technique to explore the spatially varying relationships between land use and water quality in 42 watersheds located in fars province iran. the main objective of this study is to explore how the relationships between land use and water quality indicators change over space over selected watersheds. materials and methodsthe present study was carried out in fars province iran and water quality data from 1971 to 2011 were obtained from the water company authority in fars. the water quality parameters consist of ca cl ec co3 hco3 k mg na ph th sar so4 and tds. seven land use types including bare soils rangelands fallow agricultural orchards residential and forest lands were selected in this study in this study. the land use map was created and validated by utilizing the landsat tm images (12 frames in july 2010) based on the widely used remote sensing technique known as the maximum likelihood method. the spatially varying relationships between land use and water quality indicators were analyzed using gwr. water quality indicators were used as dependent variables while land use indicators were independent variables. because high correlations exist among the land use indicators each gwr model used only one land use indicator to analyze its association with one water quality indicator. there were seven land use indicators and thirteen water quality indicators. therefore the relationships for 91 (13 times 7) pairs of water quality and land use indicators were analyzed by building 91 gwr models. gwr analyses were conducted using gwr4 software package. afterwards the local parameter estimates the values of t test on the local parameter estimates and the local r2 values produced by the gwr models were mapped to give a clear visualization of the spatial variations in the relationships between land use and water quality and the abilities of the land use indicators to explain water quality. all mappings and gis analyses were performed using the arcgis 9.3. the ols models are like the following: (1)y represents the dependent variable is the intercept and is the coefficient and the independent variable represents the error term and p is the number of independent variables. the gwr model differs in that it incorporates the coordinates of each location “i” with a metric coordinates “u” and it is defined as: (2) the model gwr is calibrated using an exponential distance decay function: (3)the weight of site “j” as it effects site “i” w is calculated using the distance (d) between sites “i” and “j” with selecting “b” as the bandwidth. the weight decreases rapidly when the kernel is smaller than the distance. for this study an adaptive band was used because the density of sample sites varied across the study area. we used the global moran’s i statistics for the residuals of both ols and gwr models to test spatial dependence (autocorrelation). global models assume that relationships between water quality and explanatory variables are the same across space. this is particularly problematic given the variation in land cover and multiple sources of pollutants. to evaluate two model performances we utilized the coefficient of determination (r2) and the corrected akaike’s information criterion (aicc). the purpose of comparing gwr with ols models was to identify whether gwr models have better model performance than the corresponding ols models. the comparison was performed by comparing the model r2 and the aicc values from both gwr and ols models. a lower aicc indicates a closer approximation of the model to reality lower aicc means better model performance. results and discussionthe global r2 of gwr with comparison of r2 of ols for each pair of dependent variable (water quality indicator) and independent variable (land use indicator) indicate that a dramatic improvement in r2 of gwr over ols is observed for every pair of water quality and land use indicators. the r2 values in gwr in all watersheds were larger than 0.83 and the aicc for all water quality parameters were much smaller than the ols models. the higher values of the global r2 from gwr than the r2 from ols indicate the improvement in model performance of gwr over ols. however the statistical significances of the improvements need to be verified with aicc values. the statistical test results for improvement in model comparisons of the aicc value indicates a closer approximation of the model to reality. thus in this study a gwr model is considered to be significantly improved from its corresponding ols model if the aicc value of the gwr is at least three lower than that of the ols and the f test is significant at p value < 0.05 level. the spatial maps of the gwr model parameters reproduced for the study area in the arcgis 9.3 for ec and cl showed that rangeland fallow lands orchards and residential in the southeast bare soil and agricultural lands in the north and forest lands in the southwest of fars province have the significant increasing impact on ec indicator values. furthermore bare soils rangelands fallow and forest regions in the west agricultural areas in the southwest orchards and residential areas in the south of this province have decreasing impact on ec values. for the case of chloride (cl) bare soils rangelands agricultural areas and forest in the north orchards and fallow lands in the southeast and residential zones in the east show a significant increase impact on this indicator. in addition bare soils in the northwest rangelands fallow lands and forest in central zones orchards and residential in the south agricultural lands in the southwest of this province have not significant increase on the chloride.conclusionthis study examined the relationships between seven land use types (%) and thirteen water quality indicators using both ols and gwr models in 42 watersheds of fars province iran. most gwr models show great improvements of model performance over their corresponding ols models which is proved by f test and the comparisons of model r2 and aicc from both gwr and ols. many gwr models also successfully reduce spatial autocorrelations examined by moran&apos;s i statistics. the gwr models improved the reliabilities of the relationships between variables by reducing the spatial autocorrelations in residuals. the visualization of the gwr model local parameter estimates (beta maps) and local r2 maps in arcgis highlight the great spatial variations in the impacts of different land use types on different water quality indicators and help identify their spatial patterns.

میزبانی شده توسط پلتفرم ابری doprax.com

copyright © 2015-2023